While "
The Wild Beyond The Witchlight" has a lot going for it the reason, well one of the reasons, I really wanted it was because we were getting some official D&D 5th Edition stats to some classic NPCs, in particular,
Skylla and
Kelek two "iconic" characters that I am using in my War of the Witch Queens campaign. So I want to look at these old friends and maybe a couple of new ones too. I'll leave poor old Thaco alone with his pipe and bitterness today. Plus it is October and Horror month, so I really just want to talk about my favorites, the bad guys.
Who Are These Characters?
Long before the use of the term Iconic Characters to refer to reoccurring D&D characters in publication, there were names like Warduke, Strongheart, Ringlerun, and Kelek. They appeared in the AD&D toy line from LJN and in other media including coloring books, stickers, adventures, and sometimes even the Dungeons & Dragons cartoon. It is also one of the reasons why I have to laugh when people today will see a stuffed Owlbear and complain that "WotC is selling out and ruining D&D." They must have forgotten the Official Advanced Dungeons & Dragons™ Yoyo or Sunglasses.
Of all of these characters, there were a few standouts who got extra attention. Ringlerun, the Good Wizard would be the cover boy for the Jeff Easley recover of the AD&D Player's Handook, although many at the time did not see the connection. Kelek and Warduke would go on to get a guest spot on the D&D cartoon. Warduke in particular would go on to be a minor celebrity in D&D iconic circles, getting 1st Ed (well...Basic really), 3rd Ed, and now 5th Ed Ed stats.
We would get all their official D&D Basic and Expert set stats, not AD&D, in the product AC1 The Shady Dragon Inn. This was sort of a Rogues Gallery for BECMI D&D. You can read my review of it here.
What I would like to do here today is compare these characters from the Wild Beyond the Witchlight to their Shady Dragon Inn and Quest for the Heartstone counterparts.
The League of Malevolence
Heroes are great, but give me a "good" villain any day of the week. Here are five iconic D&D villains. I will compare them to their D&D Basic versions to see what has changed and what has stayed the same.
Kelek
First up is the leader of the League of Malevolence, our Legion of Doom for D&D. All these characters are Chaotic Evil which tracks well to their original alignments of Chaotic.
In Basic D&D Kelek was an "Evil Sorcerer" of course at this time a "Sorcerer" was the level title for a 7th level Magic-user. In 5e his class has become a Sorcerer. This actually make a lot of sense and I approve of this change. His stats are pretty much the same from edition to edition with the exception of his Charisma which goes from 7 to 17. Charisma is the "prime" stat for sorcerers. Here he is described as a sociopath. That tracks with how I have seen him in the past.
Part of this adventure is searching for a lost Unicorn horn. Well that was more or less the plot of the only D&D Cartoon to feature Kelek. If nothing else I am saying he is still after unicorn horns.
Skylla
Ah. My beloved Skylla. I was the most excited and the most worried to see what the Wizard's dev team was going to do to you. I have to say I am not disappointed. In Quest of the Heartstone, she is listed as a 6th level Warlock. Again, this time "Warlock" meaning 6th level magic-user. I do note that the TSR team avoided calling her a "Witch" at the time. Likely due to the Satanic Panic (but Warlock is fine?). Like her former boss Kelek, the level title is translated to Class here and she is a 6th level Warlock. It fits well if you ask me.
Skylla's stats are mostly the same with some tweaks to improve what she needs to be a Warlock. Though the best changes are in her background. For starters, her patron is not a demon (like I did) but rather with Baba Yaga (like...I did). Additionally they tackle the Skylla/Charmay art issue head-on as sometimes Skylla goes by the name Charmay. It's different than what I do with her, but it works out fine in my mind.
For the record, they got Skylla as close to a "witch: as D&D 5e's rules will currently allow. I think they did a great job with her. Kelek too.
Warduke
I do have to ask. Why does everyone like this guy so much? I never quite got it, but hey someone out there is looking at my nearly 30 posts about Skylla and scratching their head.
That all being said, Warduke here is fairly impressive. I think the fans will be happy. His stats are all the same in both versions. His Dread Helm in Basic gave him Infravision to 60'. The D&D 5e version only makes his eyes glow red. Well, as I have said many times, I have a pencil.
Zarak
The half-orc Assassin was just an odd dude in Basic D&D that didn't have half-orcs as monsters, let alone as a character race, nor did it have assassins. Yet there he is on page 18 of my Quest for the Heartstone. In D&D 5 he also has some strangeness. He is a full orc here BUT he is a short one to fit the AD&D/D&D Basic orcs. Though he is still a Chaotic Evil Assassin. His Dexterity gets a buff in 5e, but he loses his "boomerang" dagger!
Zargash
The evil cleric is back. He is 7th level, so that makes him an evil Bishop. Zargash is still Chaotic Evil and he worships Orcus. Stats are tweaked a bit, but otherwise he is largely the same.
Missing Evil Characters™ include, Grimsword (Evil Knight aka Anti-Paladin), Zorgan (Evil Barbarian) and Drex (Evil Warrior) all from Quest for the Heartstone. Fox Fingers (Thief) and Raven (Evil Cleric) from Shaddy Dragon Inn. In might be fun to make Raven. She is evil (but maybe not totally), and in love with Warduke. She was once friend with Mericon. Who is up in the next batch.
Valor's Call
Our group of good hereos had the real chance of being boring on one hand and overly sanctimonious on the other. Thankfully were spared the worse. They are not as interesting as our bad guys, but they are still fun and there are still some tweaks that make them worth reading and using.
Elkhorn
Our Lawful Good dwarf might have been one of the more popular figures right behind Warduke. His stats are the same in both versions. I do like how they took an essentially blank canvas and made a dwarf that is not a Flint Fireforge clone or a Dime store Thorin and gave him some goals. He is a staunch enemy of evil. If Strongheart is the founder of Valor's call, then Elkhorn is its heart.
Mercion
Ok. She is no Aleena, but Mercion is the cleric of the group. Her stats are tweaked a bit to give her better Strength and a higher level, but the Mercion in 5e is much more interesting. In what I feel is a real homage to her Basic D&D roots, she does not worship a god but rather an ideal. She believes that truth gives life to artistry and beauty. It's kind of a cool concept. If I were to use her as an NPC I would make sure she never lies about anything, ever. In fact, the brutal truth is better for her than a sweet lie.
Molliver
Molliver the good thief was not in the Shady Dragon Inn product but can be found in the Quest for the Heartstone. In Quest no gender is given for Molliver, so in the 5e book their pronouns are "they." I like it. I like it because a.) it works for the character and b.) it will certainly piss off the ones that need pissing off.
Molliver is also the only Chaotic Good member of the party. A "Lawful" thief does not make much sense really. Stats are largely the same with a buff for Dex. They even have their boots of levitation, handy for a thief.
Ringlerun
Our Lawful Good Wizard from Basic remains a Lawful Good Wizard in 5e. Never as interesting as Kelek, Elminster, or Mordenkainen he was on the cover of the Player's Handbook and a popular figure.
 |
| His arm must be tired |
He is still largely a generic wizard. He has kind of a James Randi in his later years look about him. In my games he is dead; died of old age, but that doesn't really make sense for a wizard I guess. I have some ideas forming that I might explore later. Or not. After all he was never very interesting.
Strongheart
If I have one purely AD&D gripe it is that I rarely see anyone playing a paladin a good way. "Sanctimonious Asshole" is not a Paladin. Neither is "Grim, tortured because there is so much evil in the world" isn't either. I was worried that Strongheart was going to fall into one of those two camps. Or even worse, weak Sturm Brightblade clone.
Thankfully, that is not what we got. Instead, 5e Strongheart is the kind of paladin who is all about "we should get together to defeat evil because there is so much good in the world to enjoy!" He makes a good leader. Again his stats are slightly tweaked to give him a better Strength (13 to 15) which, by the way, his D&D Basic stats were not good enough to make him an AD&D Paladin!
He was the character I was prepared to dislike the most (I have played paladins in EVERY version of D&D) and his actually was pretty cool.
It is mentioned that there are more characters in Valor's Call, off doing Good elsewhere. They do have a solid feel of "The Superfriends" here. Not s big surprise I guess. Potential other members from Quest of the Heartstone include Peralay (Elf Fighter/Mage), Figgen (Halfling Fighter or Fighter/Thief), Deeth (Fighter), Hawkler (a totally NOT the Beastmaster Ranger), Bowmarc (Good "Crusader") and Valkeer, a half-giant warrior. Of these Valkeer might the most fun to update to 5e. Of these Peralay also appears in The Shady Dragon Inn.
Other NPCs
There are plenty of other really interesting NPCs in this book. Many I plan to lift and convert back to D&D Basic for use in my War of the Witch Queens campaign.
Burly the Hobgoblin
Before D&D, a hobgoblin was more a trickster as exemplified by Puck or Robin Goodfellow. In Witchlight we have Burly a Neutral Good Hobgoblin. Ok, I'll go with that. My favorite bit is he is a hobgoblin who wears a pumpkin on his head. Now, where have I seen that before?
Bugbear. Hobgoblin. The differences are largely academic.
Likewise, Chucklehead is a goblin with a head shaped like a taffy apple.
Iggwilv the Witch Queen
Yes! Getting Skylla was one thing, getting a new Iggwilv? That's just crazy good.
This is Iggwilv after she has left the Abyss and has been hiding out in the Feywild for centuries. Here she is also known as Tasha, Natasha, and Zybilna. There is an interaction here with Kelek that plays so well into my plans it is hard not to use it all. There is an interesting Maiden-Mother-Crone aspect of Iggwilv here in the form of Tasha-Zybilna-Iggwilv.
Now I am perfectly happy with the formerly Chaotic Evil Iggwilv becoming more Chaotic Neutral as time goes on. What I am not 100% sure about is her desire to abandon all her research on the Abyss and Demons in favor of learning about the Feywild instead. But...I can live with it.
The Hour Glass Coven
I like them. Very interesting bunch of witches and hags.
The Minis
This is such an interesting group of NPCs it makes sense that there is also an equally interesting group of minis to go with them. Sadly the supply chain breakdown has pushed many of these minis till 2022. But I am really looking forward to them.
 |
| Kelek |
 |
| Skylla |
 |
| Zyblina |
Looking forward to them.
