Continuing my deep dive of Blue Rose, it's systems and world I want to see how well it Plays Well With Others. I think for the sake of argument I refer to Blue Rose when I mean the campaign world and True20 when I mean the system.
Blue Rose and d20
I am mentioning this one just to get it out of the way. Yes, you can mix and match Blue Rose/True20 with just about any d20 system. I have done this in the past but I feel something unique is lost. Much like the Borg assimilating other cultures to where their individualism is lost, d20 sucks up other games and makes them a pale imitation of D&D. Or at least D&D 3rd Edition. This is a real valuable lesson though. For something to work for my PWWO posts the uniqueness of both games, systems, books, whatever need to be retained. The d20 conversion appendix in the back of the Blue Rose core book helps a lot and it also guides how other d20-based/derived games can be converted. Just remember that "conversion" isn't the only thing I am looking for here.
Blue Rose and Ravenloft
Ahh. My original Peanut Butter and Chocolate. Also what could be one of the first, in spirit, PWWO style posts I have made here. Ravenloft was one of my favorite game worlds for 2nd Ed D&D. Heck it was my only game world for 2nd Ed. The then new 3rd Ed Ravenloft was great, but left me underwhelmed. Mixing in Blue Rose to the Ravenloft world gave me something new. Not totally new mind you, but new enough to highlight what made both games really shine. The darkness of Ravenloft made the brightness of Blue Rose even brighter and visa versa.
You can read more about my Black Rose exploits in these posts and here, Count Strahd Von Zarovich for Blue Rose / True20.
In this case, I want to convert everything Ravenloft to Blue Rose/True20.
Blue Rose + Ravenloft + Cults of Chaos
Ok, so what do you get when you combine Blue Roses, Black Roses, Red Roses and White Roses? Well...a lot of thorns to be sure, but also something pretty cool. Combining Blue Rose and Ravenloft is a given. Since Ravenloft is, more less more "Gothic Earth" than "Gothic Greyhawk" it makes a good catalyst to add other Earth-like games. Cults of Chaos is part of +Kasimir Urbanski's Dark Albion world taking place during England's War of the Roses. Let's take my Black Rose idea and extend it to outright war between the Queen and Lord Savin. Plus the Cults of Chaos are really not all that different that the Shadow Cults of Blue Rose. Dark Albion: Cults of Chaos goes into far more detail into the cults (naturally) which can add some more ideas for the cults in Blue Rose. Indeed, England, the "mythical land ... of Roses" can share a lot with the World of Aldea. Aldis is, despite everything else, a mythical version of Western Europe. And let's be honest, a world where a Golden Hart can decide the ruler of one country can have a giant frog as the ruler of another.
In truth Cults of Chaos and Blue Rose have a lot in common.
Blue Rose and D&D 5
A lot of what Blue Rose/True20 did was revolutionary. A lot of D&D5 is evolutionary. Both games though can be brought together to build something that is truly fun.
Character creation in D&D 5 is not all that different than D&D 1 when it gets right down to it. I say keep the general rules for D&D 5 but adapt some of the Blue Rose True20 ideas. For starters, use Blue Rose's Callings to replace Backgrounds. Sure there can still be an element of Background to this, but now these Callings of the characters are something that continues on. A Background in D&D5 is sometimes relegated to the "oh that was what I used to be, but I am a <<insert class>> now." Which is too bad really. Callings can, and should influence what a character does all the time.
In this case I want to convert everything over to D&D 5 with plenty of Blue Rose material still intact.
This is going to be the basis for my "Monster Naturalists" game, but I need to figure out how to use Blue Rose's/True20's non-lethal damage track with D&D5 so the monsters can be brought in alive.
+Mark Craddock over at Cross Planes has already made some conversions of various races.
Atlantis: Second Age (OmniSystem)
+Khepera Publishing) was/is very interesting update of the old Bard Games "Atlantis" and the “Arcanum” books which were written to be used with "any fantasy role-playing game" but the obvious choice was AD&D.
This game uses the Omni System. It is a bit like True20 and this can be used with True20 with a bit of tinkering. The differences are largely on of True20 having DCs and the OmniSystem having a table of Successes. The author of the game mentioned online that he was a little surprised when he saw True20 but it was an obvious case of parallel development. The natural idea is to keep True20's DCs, but use the Omni Table for Critical successes.
The book is titled “Atlantis, the Second Age” so it is Atlantis, after the Flood. A bit odd, but I’ll go with it. Plenty of information on the world and despite the name you could run it as a pre-flood/pre-sinking Atlantean empire. Tons of new races, spells and magic, all pulled from the old Bard Games books ad updated to the OmniSystem, and naturally True20. Great as a game in it’s own right or as a guide to an antediluvian time for any other game.
Now what exactly does this have to do with Blue Rose? Well the worlds are very different, but not so different that commonalities can't be found. Atlantis (sunken or not) can most certainly lie to the west of Aldis. Atlanteans share a certain level of egalitarianism and progressive social awareness with the folk of Aldis as well. It could be that Atlantis was there all this time but forgotten after the Shadow Wars. Hesparia (from Atlantis) is almost like Lar'tya (from Blue Rose) turned up to 11.
Atlantis:SA provides a larger world for Aldea and Aldis. Is it a perfect fit? By no means. But it is a fun fit. Atlantis:SA adds a number of races that are not really what Blue Rose is about (Elves, Dwarves, Goblins, Hobgoblins) but others such as the Andaman (animal headed humanoids) are close enough to the the "Change Children" of the Valdemar book by Mercedes Lackey that a strong case can be made. In A:SA they are said to be created by Atlantean Sorcerers. Ok. Or the Sorcerer Kings of BR. Tritons (A:SA) are jsut another form of Sea Folk (BR). Skills are largely treated the same way, I would just use Blue Rose's skills myself. Talents in A:SA are a lot like the Feats in BR/T20. Many of these Talents can also be used as alternate forms of Arcana. Callings in A:SA are not exactly the same as Callings in BR. They are however very similar to the Paths introduced in the Blue Rose Companion.
Magic in A:SA is a treasure trove of ideas for any BR game. While some could properly called Sorcery in BR, others are all together new, like Alchemy and Witchcraft.
If one wanted they could take all the OGC from Blue Rose and what little OGC from Atlantis that is open and create something that would work well with both. Though that is a lot of work for two effectively dead systems. Though I still enjoy this Atlantis book. The new Atlantis book from Khepera Publishing is much more polished, but is further removed from the basic Omni System (now Omega System). Plus the book lacks some of the charm of the earlier books.
Blue Rose & Birthright
Birthright campaign setting for 2nd Ed. AD&D. Whether you use the countries in BR or the ones in BR (err..that won't work) Birthright, the political intrigue between the rulers is now the main story telling element of the game. Birthright also has a lot to offer players of Blue Rose in terms of inter- and intra-court affairs. I would limit the races to Blue Rose ones; Birthright already limits races from the menagerie that was 2nd Ed AD&D.
I will say that this combination really is the ONLY time that the Golden Hart will effect what the characters could or could not do in a game.
Birthright also has that "built in maturity" factor I associate with Blue Rose. That is there is a certain audience that will enjoy playing at this level of social interaction and that audience tends to skew older. Neither Blue Rose nor Birthright are about killing things and taking their stuff. Unless of course, you are a king. And the things you kill are armies of other kings.
Makes me want to pull out my old Birthright materials! Have not even cracked them in years.
Consequently, I'd also throw the Basic adventures B11 King's Festival and B12 Queen's Harvest as intro adventures to this mix-up. Just downplay the combat aspects and change the orcs to humans.
I have one other PWWO that I want to try out, but I am thinking of posting that one by itself tomorrow.