To that end, I am a fan of both "Axanar" and "Discovery" even if they are competing and incompatible with versions of the war with the Klingon Empire.
In Discovery the war takes place around 2256-2257.
In the Axanar and FASA Trek RPG continuity, this is known as the Four Years War and takes place between 2247 and 2250.
(Note the Enterprise NCC 1701 launches in 2245, so that tracks with Discovery but off a bit for Axanar.)
Once you start digging more and more with Disco, Axanar, and FASA it becomes obvious that the continuities will never line up even by my normal desire to handwave some details in favor of others.
I enjoyed Star Trek Discovery, I also happen to like Star Trek Axanar maybe just a little bit better. Mainly for all the same reasons spelled out here: Star Trek Discovery vs Axanar Choose Your Klingon War.
I do want a universe where Adm. Ramirez gets to say, "For myself I have but one fear: destroying the dream of the Federation. Compared to such a loss I DO NOT FEAR THE KLINGON EMPIRE!"
Hey, I said I was a Trekkie.
BUT I also want a universe with Anson Mount's Captain Pike and Sonequa Martin-Green as Commander Michael Burnham.
How do I have my cake and eat it too?
So I am going to steal a page from myself.
Back when I was playtesting the Doctor Who Adventures in Time and Space RPG I converted a bunch of Angel and Ghosts of Albion characters to DWAITAS characters (easy enough to do) and ran them all through The Ghost Tower of Inverness. Only I called it the Ghost Tower of Inverness, Illinois.
Why does Inverness, IL need a Lighthouse?? |
I can replace the lighthouse and tower with the 23rd Century equivalent; a Starbase.
The Ghost Station of Inverness Five
Inverness Five. During the Federation-Klingon War, this colony was the site of one of the bloodiest battles and the greatest defeat of the Federation. Hundreds of thousands of souls were lost and many more were made homeless overnight. Inverness was a colony of four inhabited worlds rich in dilithium. To the Klingon Empire, the Inverness system is a sacred, if not holy place.
I'll take a page from Discovery and TNG and make Inverness like the Klingon monastery on Boreth. Not just holy, but also the home of Time Crystals. At the time of the war no one knew this. The humans just knew that there were large deposits of dilithium. The Klingons knew it was holy to Kahless. The battle managed to disrupt the crystals, one of which was located in the science lab on the Inverness Station, and now the place is like the Bermuda Triangle in space.
In 2352 the Protector is sent the Inverness system, getting strange readings. The system is unstable and both the Federation and the Klingon Empire have agreed to stay out of the system. The Federation considers it too dangerous and the Klingons want everyone to stay out. Both sides treat it like something akin to a battlefield graveyard.
When the Protector shows up they should send an Away Team over to the station, the source of the readings, but "chronometric interference" makes it impossible to get a good lock. So they are sent to what is basically the bottom of the station. The team has to work its way to the science lab.
Here I basically will run a version of the Ghost Tower of Inverness.
In space, the Protector is fired upon by a Klingon D6 from Axanar's time. Communications are ignored and channels to Federation Space are blocked. They are then both attacked by a Klingon cruiser from Discovery's time.
Both teams end up having to battle with Klingons from Axanar, Discovery and even smooth ridged Klingons from the time between Enterprise and The Original Series.
So weird time dilations effects. Battling anywhere from two to four different sorts of Klingons. Starfleet chatter from nearly 100 years ago about the Klingon war and the Federation is getting it's ass kicked.
I need to figure out how to up the horror elements too. After all, that is what makes this BlackStar and not just Star Trek. I do know how it will end though. Once the Away Team gets the Time Crystal aligned/sealed/destroyed/reversed to the polarity of the neutron flow, the battle will stop and the Protector will be hailed by the current era Klingons asking if they need assistance. A reminder that at this time (2352) the Klingons and the Federation are allies.
This is my homage to not just Axanar and Discovery, but also Yesterday's Enterprise, the Bermuda Triangle and the chance to do the one thing that all old school Trekkies love, and that is to battle Klingons.
In the end, the players will not know if they had really gone back in time OR if they were battling ghosts of some sort. Also, they might never find out which version of history, Axanar or Discovery, was the correct one since they all remember it both ways.
This one will be fun too.