Going to look at some more D&D 5 Witch classes today. These are all just called "The Witch." Since that was also the name of my first witch book back in 2012 I thought I should check them out. As it turns out I have one for each primary spellcasting ability, Intelligence, Wisdom, and Charisma.
For these DMSGuild classes, I am going to still follow my own rules and guidelines to make sure I am giving these a fair review.
The Witch by Jeroen Boogaard
This pdf is 8 (6 pages content, 1 cover, 1 page of spells) pages at $0.50, so right under my ¢10 per page guideline. The pdf is full color but light on art. Mind you, that is not a big deal here since the art it does have is used to good effect.
Presented here is a full 20 level spellcasting class similar in feel to the Pathfinder witch, including minor (five of these) and major hexes (also five of these). They get a full 9 levels of spell casting slots and Intelligence is their spellcasting ability. These witches also get an herbalism ability. Their subtypes are known as "Covens" so that is a good thing. There are the covens of the dragon, the ancestor, and of the wild. Each coven gets some special abilities and additional spells.
There is a spell list on the last page, but no new spells. There are some minor typos, but nothing that impedes the understanding of the text.
The Witch by Dave Rich
This PDF is 15 pages (1 cover, 10 pages content, 3 pages of Appendicies, 1 legal). No art. The pice is $3.00 PWYW. So twice my ¢10 per page guideline.
This one presents the witch class with four archetypes and a sorcerous origin. We get a full 20 levels of the witch class. Spellcasting is based on Wisdom, and the witch gets a full 9 levels of spellcasting. This class has a limit on the total number of spells known. For example, the witch has a full 22 spell slots from 1st to 9th level, but only knows 17 spells. you can choose to forget a spell of lower level when a higher one is available. Witches gain familiars here and have a number of unique powers.
The Archetypes of the witch are called Entropic Spirals here. There are the Spiral of Life, Spiral of Fate, Spiral of Bewitching, and Spiral of Glamour. There is a list of spells, with an expansion to cover Xanathar's Guide.
Appendix A covers a sorcerous origin for witches. Appendix B details the author's thoughts on the creation of this class; namely Terry Pratchett's Discworld and Mage: The Ascension.
Some neat ideas and I like the sorcerous origin.
Class: The Witch by Calum Brough
This PDF is 11 pages (1 cover, 1 table, 2 pages of spell list). I don't recall if I paid $1.02 for this or $1.27. Either way right around my ten cents per page. There is no art.
This class is designed to be an arcane variant or compliment to the Druid. A full 20 levels (as expected) with spellcasting to the 9th level of spells. This class is a Charisma-based spell caster. There are some witch powers here, some are copied over from the druid.
The Archetypes for this witch are the Maiden, Mother, and Crone. Each archetype has some nice powers to go along with it. There are no new spells.
Each of these comes close to the idea of the witch, but not the ideal witch.